One year later, net neutrality fight enters new phase

One year later, net neutrality fight enters new phase
© Getty Images

The fight over net neutrality is entering a new phase, one year after the Federal Communications Commission approved the landmark Internet rules.

Regulators are moving to develop new standards, even as critics push forward to have the courts or Congress curb or strike down the rules down entirely.

ADVERTISEMENT

Friday marked the one-year anniversary of the FCC vote adopting new rules ensuring that all Internet traffic is treated in the same way.

The measure was approved on a party-line vote at the commission, highlighting a partisan fight that shows no signs of letting up.

The rules sparked court challenges, left lawmakers scrambling to respond and the FCC with a complicated to-do list.

Under the rules, Internet service providers aren’t allowed to slow down web traffic or block it entirely. They also can’t let a website or service pay to speed up delivery of its content.

FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler and other net neutrality supporters say it's key to protecting the open Internet as we know it.

“Strong rules of the road have provided certainty for innovators & investors so [broadband] network deployment continues,” he tweeted on Friday to mark the rule's anniversary.

But to get the authority to implement the rules, the FCC fundamentally changed the way they treat Internet providers under the law. That's drawn the ire of conservatives who see it as government overreach and have vowed to undo the rules.

The debate is now focused on two questions: If the courts or Congress will block or temper the rules; and if not, how the FCC will implement them.

A federal court heard arguments last December in a industry challenge. A three-judge panel is weighing whether the FCC overstepped its powers when it reclassified Internet service to give it authority on the issue.

And a new challenge to the rules came this week in the form of legislation from conservative lawmakers — including two presidential candidates — to repeal the regulations entirely.

Sen. Mike LeeMichael (Mike) Shumway LeeHillicon Valley: Trump AG pick signals new scrutiny on tech giants | Wireless providers in new privacy storm | SEC brings charges in agency hack | Facebook to invest 0M in local news AG pick Barr wants closer scrutiny of Silicon Valley 'behemoths' Grassroots political participation is under attack in Utah and GOP is fighting back MORE’s (R-Utah) bill says the Internet rules would have "no force or effect" and would keep the FCC from enacting such measures in the future.

It's co-sponsored by Republican Sens. Ted CruzRafael (Ted) Edward CruzGroup aiming to draft Beto O’Rourke unveils first 2020 video Howard Dean looking for a 'younger, newer' Democratic nominee in 2020 Congress can stop the war on science MORE (Texas) and Marco RubioMarco Antonio RubioRussian oligarch, allies retain key ownership in company after sanctions lifted: report Senate GOP eyes 'nuclear option' for Trump nominees next week Washington fears new threat from 'deepfake' videos MORE (Fla.) — both presidential candidates as well as Sen. John CornynJohn CornynGraham angers Dems by digging into Clinton, Obama controversies Trump tells GOP senators he’s sticking to Syria and Afghanistan pullout  Texas governor, top lawmakers tell Trump not to use hurricane relief funds to build border wall MORE (R-Texas), the No. 2 Senate Republican, among others.

“So-called net neutrality leads to fewer choices, fewer opportunities, and higher prices for consumers,” Cruz said in a statement. “If the FCC turns the Internet into a regulated public utility, the innovation and creativity that has characterized the Internet from its dawn will inevitably be stifled.”

For now, the rules are in place, but some conservatives express hope that they could still be dealt a fatal blow on Capitol Hill, in the courts or by the next president's FCC.

“I am optimistic,” said Republican Commissioner Ajit Pai, a staunch and vocal opponent of the rules, in a speech at the Heritage Foundation on Friday.

“Proponents of Internet freedom have opportunity after opportunity after opportunity to strike down President Obama’s plan to regulate the Internet," he continued. "In contrast, regulatory activists must win every battle to stay the course. I like those odds."

Some on both sides of the fight have held out hope that lawmakers will reach a middle ground on net neutrality. 

Senate Commerce Committee Chairman John ThuneJohn Randolph ThuneRove warns Senate GOP: Don't put only focus on base Leaders nix recess with no shutdown deal in sight Senate advances measure bucking Trump on Russia sanctions MORE (R-S.D.) and ranking member Bill NelsonClarence (Bill) William NelsonFlorida lawmaker diagnosed with pancreatic cancer Rick Scott threw party at Florida governor’s mansion after DeSantis and family had moved in: report Restoration of voting rights by felons marks shift in Florida MORE (D-Fla.) say they are interested in pursuing compromised, but have failed to present legislation so far.

While Congress looks for a path forward and lawyers press on in the courts, the FCC is ramping up its efforts to implement the rules.

Regulators must apply new privacy rules to Internet service providers, with the commission expected to put forth its approach in the coming months.

That has already launched a heated battle between public interest advocates and industry groups.

Industry representatives say that the rules should closely resemble how the Federal Trade Commission polices privacy — even as some say the agency has relatively limited powers when it comes to guiding industry. 

Public interest groups counter that the FCC should take the opportunity to give itself stronger enforcement powers over powerful Internet providers.

Wheeler hasn’t given many clues on how he'll decide, but has said that privacy shouldn’t be viewed as new ground for the agency.

“Network privacy is something that we’ve always been involved in,” he said at January’s Consumer Electronics Show.

One thing is clear, though, for both sides: the fight over net neutrality isn't going away.

A court ruling could come this year, and the FCC could release its privacy plans as soon as next month.