FCC defends GOP commissioners' appearance at CPAC

FCC defends GOP commissioners' appearance at CPAC
© Greg Nash

The Federal Communications Commission’s (FCC) top lawyer says that Republican commissioners who attended the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) earlier this year did not violate any ethics rules.

FCC General Counsel Thomas Johnson Jr. said that the appearance by the three GOP commissioners was in line with ethics requirements because even though CPAC is an event focused on conservative viewpoints, it’s "not affiliated with any one political party," Johnson wrote in a letter obtained by The Hill that was sent last week to Democrats on the House Energy and Commerce Committee.


“The Commissioners' ability to accept prominent speaking engagements like this one helps promote transparency and accountability and encourages public participation and interest in Commission rulemakings, without contravening applicable ethics obligations,” Johnson wrote. 

Democrats had complained about the GOP commissioners' presence at CPAC.   

Reps. Frank Pallone Jr.Frank Joseph PalloneHouse Democrats urge Amazon to investigate, recall 'defective' products Asbestos ban stalls in Congress amid partisan fight Pharma execs say FDA will not lower standards for coronavirus vaccine MORE (D-N.J.) and Mike DoyleMichael (Mike) F. DoyleBiden's gain is Democratic baseball's loss with Cedric Richmond White House getting pushback on possible government-owned 5G network Hillicon Valley: DOJ accuses Russian hackers of targeting 2018 Olympics, French elections | Federal commission issues recommendations for securing critical tech against Chinese threats | House Democrats slam FCC over 'blatant attempt to help' Trump MORE (D-Pa.), in a letter to the three Republican commissioners who attended the event in January, argued that their appearance raised concerns about their fitness to lead an independent agency. The letter included a list of questions about whether they had spent taxpayer money on the event or consulted ethics officials ahead of time.

CPAC 4.16.2018 


In a statement to The Hill, Pallone blasted Johnson’s letter, accusing the Republicans of ducking congressional oversight of their “increasingly political actions.”

“We asked the Commissioners legitimate questions and expected them to respond, not to hide behind their lawyer,” Pallone said. “The general counsel did not provide any legal reason why the Commissioners could not respond, and we still expect the Commissioners to answer our questions."

An FCC spokeswoman was not immediately able to comment.

Johnson argued in his letter that past commissioners had appeared at events hosted by groups on both the left and right, including the Center for American Progress, the Heritage Foundation and the Progressive Policy Institute. Such appearances don't violate ethics laws like the Hatch Act, Johnson wrote, because those organizations aren't affiliated with a political party.

"Because participation at CPAC is not political activity, as defined by the Hatch Act, there was no need for any Commissioner to abide by the limitations that the Act places on the use of appropriated funds, official staff, or agency resources in connection with such activity," reads the letter, dated April 16.

Ahead of the CPAC panel event, FCC Chairman Ajit Pai was given a courage award by the National Rifle Association and the American Conservative Union — the organization that hosts CPAC — for his efforts to repeal the FCC’s net neutrality rules under withering criticism. Pai later declined the award, citing the advice of agency ethics officials.