SPONSORED:

Lawmakers deride FTC settlement as weak on Facebook

Lawmakers deride FTC settlement as weak on Facebook
© Getty

Lawmakers on both sides of the aisle on Wednesday derided the Federal Trade Commission's (FTC) record-breaking settlement with Facebook as weak, arguing that the final agreement does not hit Facebook's core business model and does not require extensive government oversight of the company accused of flagrantly violating Americans' privacy.

Almost as soon as the FTC announced its $5 billion settlement with Facebook on Wednesday morning, lawmakers in both chambers emerged with scathing criticism, calling the agreement a slap on the wrist for a company that recorded almost $56 billion in revenue last year.

ADVERTISEMENT

"This fig leaf deal releases Facebook without requiring any real privacy protections—no restraints on future data use, no accountability for top executives, nothing more than chump change financial fines," Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) said in a statement. "The record is now clear: Facebook egregiously and repeatedly broke the law, turning a blind eye to abuse and putting its rapacious rush to profits ahead of the safety of its users."

Sen. Ron WydenRonald (Ron) Lee WydenSenators call for passage of bill to cement alcohol excise tax relief The Hill's Morning Report - Presented by Mastercard - GOP angst in Georgia; confirmation fight looms Alcohol industry ramps up pressure on Congress for tax relief MORE (D-Ore.), one of the top privacy hawks in Congress, in a statement slammed the FTC for giving "Facebook and executives like Mark ZuckerbergMark Elliot ZuckerbergFacebook-backed cryptocurrency Libra changes names Democrats urge YouTube to remove election misinformation, step up efforts ahead of Georgia runoff Democrats press Facebook, Twitter on misinformation efforts ahead of Georgia runoff MORE and Sheryl Sandberg blanket immunity for violations of the law we know about, and even for potential crimes that are still unknown."

"The FTC is sending the message that wealthy executives and massive corporations can rampantly violate Americans’ privacy, lie about how our personal information is used and abused and get off with no meaningful consequences," he said.

On the other side of the aisle, outspoken tech critic Sen. Josh HawleyJoshua (Josh) David HawleyTime to bring federal employees home for every holiday Biden's Cabinet a battleground for future GOP White House hopefuls The Memo: GOP mulls its future after Trump MORE (R-Mo.) slammed the deal for doing "nothing to change Facebook's creepy surveillance of its own users [and] the misuse of user data. It does nothing to hold executives accountable. It utterly fails to penalize Facebook in any effective way."

As part of the settlement, Facebook is not required to admit to any wrongdoing; the agreement requires the company to create a privacy committee within its board of directors to review company decisions and provide more oversight of Chairman and CEO Mark Zuckerberg

The FTC voted for the settlement along party lines, with both Democratic commissioners dissenting in separate statements claiming Facebook escaped relatively unscathed.

"The settlement imposes no meaningful changes to the company's structure or financial incentives, which led to these violations," Democratic Commissioner Rohit Chopra said in his statement. "Nor does it include any restrictions on the company's mass surveillance or advertising tactics."

"Instead, the order allows Facebook to decide for itself how much information it can harvest from users and what it can do with that information, as long as it creates a paper trail," he added, referring to FTC settlement's requirements that Facebook documents its attempts to put privacy safeguards in place.

The settlement emerges after a more than year-long investigation began last year following news that Cambridge Analytica, a British political consulting firm, had bought data on millions of Facebook users without their knowledge from the developer of a personality quiz app.

On Wednesday, the FTC announced Facebook deceived its users about their privacy protections while allowing third parties to harvest their data, alleging the company failed to establish a "reasonable privacy program."

At a press conference on Wednesday afternoon, the Republican commissioners, including Chairman Joseph Simons, defended the deal as the best possible option for a regulatory agency with limited resources in a country without a federal privacy law.

Simons repeatedly noted that the FTC's investigation narrowly focused on whether Facebook violated a previous consent order and a 100 year-old FTC statute that was not written for modern-day data privacy issues. He said the FTC faced two options: to take the concessions offered in the settlement or to take Facebook to court, a battle that might have dragged on for years.  

Neither of the Democratic commissioners attended the press conference.

Multiple lawmakers pointed out that the penalties could have been tougher if the U.S. had a privacy law. Since the FTC's investigation began over a year ago, lawmakers have not been able to work up significant draft privacy legislation as talks have broken down within a privacy working group under the Senate Commerce Committee.

Sen. Maria CantwellMaria Elaine CantwellTwo more parting shots from Trump aimed squarely at disabled workers Senate advances energy regulator nominees despite uncertainty of floor vote OVERNIGHT DEFENSE: Esper reportedly working with lawmakers to strip Confederate names from bases | Enemy attacks in Afghanistan jump by 50 percent, watchdog says | Fort Hood soldier arrested, charged in Chelsea Cheatham killing MORE (D-Wash.), the ranking member of the committee who recently chose to step back from the working group, said the decision "underscores the need for strong privacy legislation."

The FTC's budget is about $300 million per year, a sum that pales in comparison to the billions of dollars in revenue accrued by the the world's top tech companies annually. And it only has around 40 staffers focused on privacy specifically. Many lawmakers have floated the possibility that privacy legislation would offer more resources and potentially more authority to the FTC.

ADVERTISEMENT

“While $5 billion is a record fine for the FTC, monetary damages are not enough," House Energy and Commerce Chairman Frank Pallone (D-N.J.) said. "Comprehensive privacy legislation is necessary to strengthen the FTC’s authorities and give it more enforcement tools and resources so that violating consumers’ privacy and breaking public trust isn’t just the cost of doing business.” 

Some lawmakers on Capitol Hill, however, have applauded the settlement, noting that it is one of the largest ever imposed by the FTC related to privacy issues.

"Today’s settlement announced by the FTC against Facebook is one of the largest civil penalties ever imposed by the U.S. government and it is by far the largest privacy or data security settlement the world has seen yet," top House Energy and Commerce Committee Republicans, Rep. Greg WaldenGregory (Greg) Paul WaldenHillicon Valley: Leadership changes at top cyber agency raise national security concerns | Snapchat launches in-app video platform 'Spotlight' | Uber, Lyft awarded federal transportation contract Lawmakers urge FCC to assist in effort to rip out, replace suspect network equipment OVERNIGHT ENERGY: Barrasso to seek top spot on Energy and Natural Resources Committee | Forest Service finalizes rule weakening environmental review of its projects | Biden to enlist Agriculture, Transportation agencies in climate fight MORE (Ore) and Cathy McMorris RodgersCathy McMorris RodgersOVERNIGHT ENERGY: Republicans in campaign mode for top spots on House environmental committees | Peterson loss prompts scramble for House Agriculture chair Republicans in campaign mode for top spots on House environmental committees Conservatives seize on New York Post story to push Section 230 reform MORE (Wash.) said in a statement.

But the Republicans vowed to exercise oversight over the FTC to ensure the conditions of the settlement are met and to "continue our work on a federal privacy framework that sets clear rules of the road to protect consumers."

Senate Commerce Committee Chairman Roger WickerRoger Frederick WickerGOP lawmaker patience runs thin with Trump tactics Republicans start turning the page on Trump era The Hill's Morning Report - Sponsored by Facebook - Trump, Biden blitz battleground states MORE (R-Miss.) echoed those sentiments, noting "bad actors will be able to continue to abuse data in the online marketplace" without privacy legislation. 

Each FTC commissioner has pushed for legislation to bolster the agency's work on tech issues. But ultimately, the agency's Democrats argued the settlement could have gone further with the authority it has. The settlement does not specifically punish  Zuckerberg and the agency did not depose him as part of its investigation.

Zuckerberg said in a post on Wednesday that the settlement will require Facebook to make "major structural changes" to how it does business.