Judge orders Tesla to turn over documents on Musk compensation plan

Judge orders Tesla to turn over documents on Musk compensation plan
© Getty Images

A judge on Monday ordered Tesla to turn over documents detailing communications between CEO Elon MuskElon Reeve MuskOn The Money: IRS to start monthly payments of child tax credit July 15 | One-fourth of Americans took financial hits in 2020: Fed Putting the brakes on cryptocurrencies: Well done Elon Musk Hillicon Valley: Parler's return to Apple store poses new challenges | Biden revokes Trump-era order targeting shield for website operators MORE and Tesla's in-house counsel regarding discussions surrounding a compensation plan Musk presented to Tesla's board of directors in 2018.

The Associated Press reported that a judge in Delaware ordered that the communications between Musk and his in-house counsel are not protected, while ruling that other communications sought by attorneys for shareholders remained protected, including communications between other Tesla board members.

Shareholders have accused Tesla of approving a massive compensation plan for Musk that they believe was crafted by Tesla's in-house counsel, Todd Maron, and deputy in-house counsel, Jonathan Chang, without input from the board of directors. Tesla has denied the claims.


The company approved a compensation plan for Musk in 2018 that could be worth more than $50 billion. Musk also runs SpaceX, a private spaceflight company, that is aiming to put private astronauts in space around the moon by 2023.

“Leveraging his control, close personal relationships, and reputation for retribution, Musk co-opted Maron and Chang to help him structure the plan free from committee involvement,” the plaintiffs’ attorneys wrote in motions asking for the communications to be released, according to the AP.

“Musk and his agents handed the committee a fully-baked plan,” they reportedly continued.

The Hill has reached out to Tesla for comment.