Judge throws out lawsuit against South Carolina GOP for canceling 2020 primary

Judge throws out lawsuit against South Carolina GOP for canceling 2020 primary

A judge in South Carolina on Wednesday threw out a lawsuit against the state’s Republican Party for canceling its 2020 presidential primary.

Jocelyn Newman, a state court judge, ruled that the South Carolina Republican Party (SCGOP) acted within its rights when it chose to cancel the primary.

“The law does not give Plaintiffs a legal right to presidential preference primary, and the Court will not substitute its own judgment for that of the General Assembly or the SCGOP,” Newman wrote in her decision.


The lawsuit was filed in October by former Rep. Bob Inglis (R-S.C.) and GOP voter Frank Heindel, who argued that the SCGOP had denied them their right to vote for their party’s presidential nominee.

“We had hoped for an opportunity for all South Carolina Republicans to vote in the First in the South primary in 2020, but that is not to be,” Inglis said in a statement.

The SCGOP’s executive committee voted 43-1 in September to cancel the primary and essentially endorse President TrumpDonald John TrumpSenate Republicans muscle through rules for Trump trial Collins breaks with GOP on attempt to change impeachment rules resolution Roberts admonishes House managers, Trump lawyers after heated exchange MORE’s reelection. 

Drew McKissick, the state’s Republican Party chairman, said at the time that the move would also save taxpayers money.

“With no legitimate primary challenger and President Trump’s record of results, the decision was made to save South Carolina taxpayers over $1.2 million and forgo an unnecessary primary,” McKissick said. “President Trump and his administration have delivered for South Carolinians, and we look forward to ensuring that Republican candidates up and down the ballot are elected in 2020.”


Cameron Kistler, a lawyer with Protect Democracy representing Inglis and Heindel, said that they are evaluating their options to “ensure that every South Carolina Republican has a voice this primary season.”

“We respectfully disagree with the judge's decision that presidential preference primaries are different than official primaries,” Kistler said in a statement. “Party bosses shouldn’t be able to cancel elections and deny hundreds of thousands of voters their voice in selecting presidential candidates.”

Former Rep. Joe WalshJoe WalshWalsh plans protest at RNC headquarters over 'nakedly anti-Democratic' primary cancellations Pelosi announced as lead guest on season premiere of 'Real Time with Bill Maher' Rep. Collins says Democrats are 'in love with terrorists,' 'mourn Soleimani' MORE (R-Ill.) and former Massachusetts Gov. William WeldWilliam (Bill) WeldWeld says Trump wants reporters to 'roam free' in Iran, but not US Trump primary challengers left off Wisconsin ballot Bannon: 'We need the Republican establishment on board' to reelect Trump MORE (R) have launched long-shot GOP primary challenges to Trump. Former Rep. Mark SanfordMark SanfordTrump challenger Bill Weld rules out 2020 independent bid Judge throws out lawsuit against South Carolina GOP for canceling 2020 primary The Hill's Campaign Report: Late bids surprise 2020 Democratic field MORE (R-S.C.) dropped out of the Republican primary race in November.